Source: Sumner County Archives
Note: Note: There are 3 different Member lists, some containing the same names.
| No. | Name | When Received | How Received | By Whom Received | Date of Death or Disposal |
| 1 | Mrs. Sebella T. Fulks | 1852 | Transferred to Greenbrier, Jan. 1, 1899 | ||
| 2 | Mrs. Nancy Lassiter | Died Dec 5 1899 | |||
| 3 | Mrs. Sallie Hall | Died 1899 | |||
| 4 | Mrs. Indianna Sanders | ||||
| 5 | O. B. Saunders | ||||
| 6 | Mrs. Catherine Perry | Died April 5, 1886 | |||
| 7 | B. F. Perry | 1881 | |||
| 8 | Mrs. Mollie Carr | ||||
| 9 | Mrs. Hattie Yount | ||||
| 10 | Chas. H. Fisher | 1875 | By Baptism | Jno Bell | |
| 11 | Miss. Katie Fisher | 1875 | By Baptism | Jno Bell | Married Robt. Lassiter 1886 |
| 12 | Miss. Lucy Fisher | 1881 | By Baptism | J. W. Keathley | Married Jesse T. Bruce 1894? |
| 13 | William Lassiter | 1881 | By Baptism | J. W. Keathley | |
| 14 | Mrs. Malinda Lewis | ||||
| 15 | Jesse J. Payne | 1885 | By Baptism | W. R. Keathley | |
| 16 | Miss. Valeria Yount | July 1 1887 | By Baptism | Samuel Wilson Bransford | Married Henry C. Lassiter |
| 17 | Miss. Nettie Bruce | July 1 1887 | By Baptism | Samuel Wilson Bransford | Died July 21, 1958 |
| 18 | Mrs. Eliza Jane Reasoner | July 2 1887 | By Certificate | Samuel Wilson Bransford | Married Mathis |
| 19 | Miss. Lulu E. Perry | July 2 1887 | By Baptism | Samuel Wilson Bransford | Married Marvin Lassiter |
| 20 | Miss. Minnie Vet__la? Pike | July 2 1887 | By Baptism | Samuel Wilson Bransford | Married Haley |
| 21 | Harris B. Savely | July 2 1887 | By Baptism | Samuel Wilson Bransford | Died 1902 or 4 |
| 22 | Mrs. Viola A. Fulcher | July 19 1888 | By Baptism | Samuel Wilson Bransford | |
| 23 | James A. Templeton | Aug 26 1888 | By Certificate | Samuel Wilson Bransford | |
| 24 | Absolom J. Templeton | Aug 26 1888 | By Vows | Samuel Wilson Bransford | |
| 25 | Mrs. Sarah Elliza Templeton | Aug 26, 1888 | By Certificate | Samuel Wilson Bransford | |
| 26 | Jacob M. Yount | Sept 21, 1889 | By Baptism | Thomas S. Collum | Died |
| 27 | James M. Bruce | Sept 12, 1890 | By Profession | Thomas S. Collum | Died |
| 28 | Prudence Templeton | Sept 12, 1890 | Seekers | Thomas S. Collum | Married Horner |
| 29 | Mrs. Sarah C. Wilkerson | Sept 12, 1890 | By Vows | Jno W. Rice | Home died 1903 or 4 |
| 30 | L. J. Mathis | Sept 10 1893 | By Vows | J. J. Pitts | |
| No number | John A. Fulcher | ? | ? | ? | Died __? 13 1904 |
| 31 | Winnie S. Fulcher | Sept 10 1893 | By Baptism | ||
| 32 | Virgie McMurtry | Sept 10 1893 | By Baptism | ||
| 33 | Jos A. Bruce | Sept 10 1893 | By Baptism | ||
| 34 | Maggie Jones | Sept 10 1893 | By Vows | ||
| 35 | Maggie Templeton | Sept 10 1893 | By Vows | ||
| 36 | Peter Lewis | Sept 10 1893 | On Trial | ||
| 37 | Erwin Baxter Fulcher | Sept 10 1893 | By Baptism | ||
| 38 | Carlton Fulcher | Sept 10 1893 | By Baptism | ||
| 39 | Willie Fulcher | Sept 10 1893 | By Baptism | ||
| 40 | Mabel Fulcher | Sept 10 1893 | By Baptism | ||
| 41 | Robt. H. Horner | Sept 10 1893 | By Certificate | ||
| 42 | George Lackey | Sept 10 1893 | Candidate | ||
| 43 | Edward Gourley | Oct 1893 | By Baptism | ||
| 44 | Daisy Gourley | Oct 1893 | By Baptism | ||
| 45 | Ada Sanders | Sept 9 1894 | By Baptism | ||
| 46 | Robt Sanders | Sept 9 1894 | Candidate | ||
| 47 | Nora Sanders | Sept 9 1894 | By Baptism | ||
| 48 | Jas Carr | Sept 9 1894 | By Baptism | ||
| 49 | Mary Jones | Sept 9 1894 | By Baptism | ||
| 50 | J. A. Hudgins | Sept 9 1894 | By Baptism | ||
| 51 | J. T. Jones | Sept 9 1894 | By Baptism | ||
| 52 | Mildred Sanders | Sept 9 1894 | By Vows | ||
| 53 | Robt Lassiter | Sept 9, 1894 | By Baptism | ||
| 54 | Jesse Bruce | Sept 9, 1894 | By Baptism | ||
| 55 | Clara E. Payne | April 27, 1895 | Renewal | ||
| 56 | Katie Fisher | May 26, 1895 | By Bap. on prof. | ||
| 57 | Willis Y. Bagwell | Oct 12, 1895 | By Vows | ||
| 58 | By Vows | ||||
| 59 | J. G. Carrley ? | March 10 1933 | By Certificate | ||
| 60 | Mrs. J. G. Caring ? | March 10 1933 | By Certificate |